A developer I know just showed me FubuMVC and there was some question whether or not we should attempt to use it on a real live project or not. The current design choice so far has been ASP.NET MVC.
我认识的一个开发人员刚刚向我展示了FubuMVC，有人问我们是否应该在真实的项目中使用它。目前的设计选择是ASP。净MVC。
What I'm interested in finding out is:
我感兴趣的是:
What are the core differences between ASP.NET MVC and FubuMVC?
ASP之间的核心区别是什么?净MVC和FubuMVC吗?
What are the gains/loses with either framework?
这两个框架的得失是什么?
Is FubuMVC ready for prime time?
FubuMVC准备好了吗?
Which of these two would you use on a new project?
在一个新项目中，你会使用这两种方法中的哪一种?
4 个解决方案
#1
17
@maz It depends what your application is going to do, its timeframe, its criticality, etc.
@maz它取决于你的应用程序将要做什么，它的时间框架，它的危害性等等。
First, I'd encourage you to mess around with both. Neither is better or worse than the other overall, they are different and each have significant strengths and weaknesses that you should consider.
首先，我鼓励你把两者都弄得一团糟。两者都不比另一个好或坏，它们是不同的，每个都有你应该考虑的重要的优点和缺点。
At this point, ASP.NET MVC is more mature and has had more testers and eyeballs looking at it. So if you are doing any sort of serious project (i.e. you're getting paid for it), I would encourage you, at this point, to use ASP.NET MVC as it's going to "ship" sooner and be more supported.
在这一点上,ASP。NET MVC更加成熟，已经有了更多的测试人员和关注者。因此，如果你正在做任何严肃的项目(例如，你得到了报酬)，我鼓励你，在这一点上，使用ASP。NET MVC，因为它将会“发布”得更快，并且更受支持。
(UPDATE [26 Feb 2011]): FubuMVC is now being used by several companies and teams in mature, production apps that have had several major released versions based on FubuMVC. While the documentation is still lacking somewhat, the quality of the framework is now well established as production-worthy)
(更新[2011年2月26日]):FubuMVC现在被几个公司和团队在成熟的生产应用程序中使用，这些应用程序基于FubuMVC发布了几个主要版本。虽然文档仍然有些缺乏，但是框架的质量现在已经被很好地确定为值得生产的)
If you're starting a hobby project (i.e. personal blog, personal/family photo album, etc) then I'd invite you to pick up FubuMVC and start playing with it. Keep in mind that this point it's basically a hobby of mine, Jeremy's, and a few others so there's no guarantees on timeline, etc. It hasn't really been publicly announced (it's leaked out, for better or worse) so there hasn't been a flood of contributions yet. I'm hoping as it matures and we get to the first milestone then announce it to the wide, wide world, contributions will ramp up.
如果你正在开始一个兴趣项目(比如个人博客、个人/家庭相册等)，那么我邀请你拿起FubuMVC开始玩。请记住这一点，这基本上是我、杰里米和其他一些人的爱好，所以对时间表没有保证，等等。它并没有真正被公开宣布(不管是好是坏)，所以还没有大量的捐款。我希望随着它的成熟，我们到达第一个里程碑，然后向全世界宣布，捐款将会增加。
In the end, using either will likely encourage better development practices over, say, ASP.NET WebForms and getting familiar with the one will make it easier for you to pick up the other one rather quickly.
最后，使用任何一种方法都可能鼓励更好的开发实践，而不是使用ASP。NET WebForms和熟悉其中一个会让你更容易快速地找到另一个。
It really comes down to the criticality of the project you're working on, so choose responsibly.
这实际上取决于你正在做的项目的关键，所以要负责任地选择。
#2
9
It seems that the main difference is that FubuMVC implements the Front Controller pattern.
主要的区别在于FubuMVC实现了前端控制器模式。
If ASP.NET MVC is not ready for prime time yet (it's in Beta), I would doubt that FubuMVC would be ready, since it's kind of a fork from the former.
如果ASP。NET MVC还没有为黄金时间做好准备(它还在Beta版中)，我怀疑FubuMVC是否已经准备好了，因为它有点类似于前者。
The guys behind FubuMVC are quite good though, Chad Myers and Jeremy D. Miller are very respected among the community and very active members of ALT.NET. But so is Phill Haack, Scott Hanselman& Co, the guys behind ASP.NET MVC.
FubuMVC背后的人很不错，查德·迈尔斯和杰里米·d·米勒在社区中很受人尊敬，而且是ALT.NET的活跃成员。不过，ASP背后的菲尔·哈克(Phill Haack)、斯科特·汉瑟曼公司(Scott hanselman&co)也是如此。净MVC。
If you just want to get started I would recommend ASP.NET MVC because it has more people and resources behind it, and go for Fubu if you don't like what you see.
如果你只是想开始，我推荐ASP。NET MVC，因为它后面有更多的人和资源，如果你不喜欢你看到的，就去Fubu。
#3
3
I haven't used Fubu Mvc but just looked at it. It's not finished but I might use it on partially rewriting an existing non-web winforms project. Asp.Net Mvc is for web projects only.
我还没有用过Fubu Mvc，只是看看而已。它还没有完成，但我可能会在部分重写现有的非web winforms项目时使用它。Asp。Net Mvc只适用于web项目。
#1
17
@maz It depends what your application is going to do, its timeframe, its criticality, etc.
@maz它取决于你的应用程序将要做什么，它的时间框架，它的危害性等等。
First, I'd encourage you to mess around with both. Neither is better or worse than the other overall, they are different and each have significant strengths and weaknesses that you should consider.
首先，我鼓励你把两者都弄得一团糟。两者都不比另一个好或坏，它们是不同的，每个都有你应该考虑的重要的优点和缺点。
At this point, ASP.NET MVC is more mature and has had more testers and eyeballs looking at it. So if you are doing any sort of serious project (i.e. you're getting paid for it), I would encourage you, at this point, to use ASP.NET MVC as it's going to "ship" sooner and be more supported.
在这一点上,ASP。NET MVC更加成熟，已经有了更多的测试人员和关注者。因此，如果你正在做任何严肃的项目(例如，你得到了报酬)，我鼓励你，在这一点上，使用ASP。NET MVC，因为它将会“发布”得更快，并且更受支持。
(UPDATE [26 Feb 2011]): FubuMVC is now being used by several companies and teams in mature, production apps that have had several major released versions based on FubuMVC. While the documentation is still lacking somewhat, the quality of the framework is now well established as production-worthy)
(更新[2011年2月26日]):FubuMVC现在被几个公司和团队在成熟的生产应用程序中使用，这些应用程序基于FubuMVC发布了几个主要版本。虽然文档仍然有些缺乏，但是框架的质量现在已经被很好地确定为值得生产的)
If you're starting a hobby project (i.e. personal blog, personal/family photo album, etc) then I'd invite you to pick up FubuMVC and start playing with it. Keep in mind that this point it's basically a hobby of mine, Jeremy's, and a few others so there's no guarantees on timeline, etc. It hasn't really been publicly announced (it's leaked out, for better or worse) so there hasn't been a flood of contributions yet. I'm hoping as it matures and we get to the first milestone then announce it to the wide, wide world, contributions will ramp up.
如果你正在开始一个兴趣项目(比如个人博客、个人/家庭相册等)，那么我邀请你拿起FubuMVC开始玩。请记住这一点，这基本上是我、杰里米和其他一些人的爱好，所以对时间表没有保证，等等。它并没有真正被公开宣布(不管是好是坏)，所以还没有大量的捐款。我希望随着它的成熟，我们到达第一个里程碑，然后向全世界宣布，捐款将会增加。
In the end, using either will likely encourage better development practices over, say, ASP.NET WebForms and getting familiar with the one will make it easier for you to pick up the other one rather quickly.
最后，使用任何一种方法都可能鼓励更好的开发实践，而不是使用ASP。NET WebForms和熟悉其中一个会让你更容易快速地找到另一个。
It really comes down to the criticality of the project you're working on, so choose responsibly.
这实际上取决于你正在做的项目的关键，所以要负责任地选择。
#2
9
It seems that the main difference is that FubuMVC implements the Front Controller pattern.
主要的区别在于FubuMVC实现了前端控制器模式。
If ASP.NET MVC is not ready for prime time yet (it's in Beta), I would doubt that FubuMVC would be ready, since it's kind of a fork from the former.
如果ASP。NET MVC还没有为黄金时间做好准备(它还在Beta版中)，我怀疑FubuMVC是否已经准备好了，因为它有点类似于前者。
The guys behind FubuMVC are quite good though, Chad Myers and Jeremy D. Miller are very respected among the community and very active members of ALT.NET. But so is Phill Haack, Scott Hanselman& Co, the guys behind ASP.NET MVC.
FubuMVC背后的人很不错，查德·迈尔斯和杰里米·d·米勒在社区中很受人尊敬，而且是ALT.NET的活跃成员。不过，ASP背后的菲尔·哈克(Phill Haack)、斯科特·汉瑟曼公司(Scott hanselman&co)也是如此。净MVC。
If you just want to get started I would recommend ASP.NET MVC because it has more people and resources behind it, and go for Fubu if you don't like what you see.
如果你只是想开始，我推荐ASP。NET MVC，因为它后面有更多的人和资源，如果你不喜欢你看到的，就去Fubu。
#3
3
I haven't used Fubu Mvc but just looked at it. It's not finished but I might use it on partially rewriting an existing non-web winforms project. Asp.Net Mvc is for web projects only.
我还没有用过Fubu Mvc，只是看看而已。它还没有完成，但我可能会在部分重写现有的非web winforms项目时使用它。Asp。Net Mvc只适用于web项目。