Midjourney V5 比 V4 更好吗？Prompt 全公开（上篇）

Midjourney V5 发布好几天了，做个晚到的全面评测。分为上下两篇发布：

V5 的惊艳之处：

photograpy，CG rendering, HD film style 类生成
Prompt 控制准确度的基本测试
V5 比 V4 的更好的地方：

在 V5 里可以准确控制镜头语言，光影也更真实自然
V5 相比 V4 倒退的地方：

V5 会让构图更碎片化、产生更多不必要的细节，成像的锐利和清晰程度下降

V5 的惊艳之处：photograpy，CGI rendering，HD film style 类生成

下面是一些我这几天用 V5 跑的照片写实类 photo realism，可以跟我之前在 Stable Diffusion 2.0 发布时写的评测文章做比较，用了一部分相同的生成主题。

Photography a beautiful Eyes of reptiles, eyes of lizards, blue and golden pupil, close-up view, dark clear background, Minimalism, artistic, atmospheric, masterpiece, HDR, hyper-detailed, 500px

水下场景的表现非常不错，光影和水波反射的处理都非常真实。

fine-art underwater photography of swiming pool, Stunning Photos of running horse underwater, full body horse, bright, artistic, magic time, atmospheric, masterpiece, vivid color, HDR, super-realistic, sharp focus, super detailed, 500px, 8K, wallpaper

fine-art underwater photography of swiming pool, Stunning Photos of a smiling baby swiming underwater, High-speed photography, HDR, artistic, Minimalism, super-realistic, magic time, sunset, golden shining, atmospheric, masterpiece, 8K, wallpaper,

fine-art Photography a beautiful eye, super realistic pupil, close-up view, dark clear background, Minimalism, artistic, atmospheric, masterpiece, HDR, golden ratio composition, hyper-detailed, 500px

photography of a Clear crystal cube, floating highly on the sky, the tumultuous sea, Arctic Ocean, sunset, magic time, HDR, Minimalism, artistic, atmospheric, futuristic,hyper-detailed, 8K wallpaper, HDR, 500px

fine-art Photography Praying Hands, super realistic , close-up view, dark clear background, Minimalism, artistic, atmospheric, masterpiece, HDR, golden ratio composition, hyper-detailed, 500px

close-up of the ace of spades and a silver bullet beside a glass of whiskey on an oak table in an old western saloon

金属材质的渲染

liquid metal, flowing, splash, dark and golden, Ribbon-like shine, hyper-detailed, photorealistic, studio light, amazing texture, sharp focus (left)| artwork by Georg Jensen (right)

黑白胶片风格和电影风格的照片生成

by Bert Hardy , city landscape

by Josef Koudelka , a old man wearing winter coat walking toward a snowy beach, winter ocean, photorealistic, cinematic, hyper-detailed

by Josef Koudelka , stunning natural landscape, church

你可以用 a scene from the movie **** ，配合一个超宽的比例，生成很多电影场景，比如下面五张教父系列。

in style of Bert Hardy, A scene from the movie “The Godfather,” Film noir, natural lighting, Fujifilm, Luxurious, Historical, 4k

in style of Bert Hardy, street view, small church, Film noir, wide shot, Film Lighting, Fujifilm, Luxurious, cinematic still::1, 16k

in style of Bert Hardy, A scene from the movie “The Godfather,” Film noir, natural lighting, Fujifilm, Luxurious, Historical, 4k

人像生成

Editorial style photo, medium closeup shot, off-center, a young, brunette, french woman, sitting at a Marble Table, wearing a black gucci dress and diamond necklace, in an Art Deco Dining Room with Velvet, Brass, and Mirror accents, Jewel Toned color pallete, West Elm, Chandelier, Restaurant, Evening, natural lighting, Fujifilm, Luxurious, Historical, 4k

by Bert Hardy , portrait, half body, super-detailed, high quality

支持 image split （下面的生成看起来像是两张图，但实际上是一张，在 Prompt 里使用 image split into 2，就可以得到同一角色 + 同一服饰的但不同视角的两种生成结果。你也可以尝试 2 倍以上的 split, 然后再进行高倍 upscale）

一张近景，一张膝高镜头

‍futuristic hotel lady wearing the white uniform, magenta hair and eye shadows, futuristic white hotel lobby, magenta furniture and props, Japanese SF film, inorganic world, hyper realistic, image split into 2, close up and knee shot of the lady — ar 2:1

(Prompt inspired by @Dir_NIWATCH /Dir_NIWATCH?s=20)

futuristic hotel Bounty hunter standing, wearing the black leather jacket, Japanese SF film, inorganic world, hyper realistic, image split into 2, close up and knee shot of the man, Gangsters, dirty little bars, wooden table — ar 2:1

V5 里也支持 3:1 这种超宽比例或 1:3 超高比例

by Josef Koudelka , a old man wearing winter coat walking toward a snowy beach, winter ocean, photorealistic, cinematic, hyper-detailed — ar 3:1

CG 渲染类的生成

a cat talking to a old man, cyberpunk, Cinematic, super-details, Unreal Engine, DOF, super resolution, megapixel, cinematic lighting, anti-aliasing, CGI, VFX, SFX, hyper maximalist, hyper-realistic, volumetric, photorealistic, full colors, volumetric lighting, realistic, 16K, sharp focus

a cyborg robot with humanoid face, holding a black cat, cyberpunk,super-details, Unreal Engine, DOF, super resolution, megapixel, cinematic lighting, anti-aliasing, CGI, VFX, SFX, hyper maximalist, hyper-realistic, volumetric, photorealistic, full colors, volumetric lighting, realistic, 16K, sharp focus

half-body portrait of a cyberpunk warrior, super-realistic, half body, HDR, vivid color, Cinematic, super-details, Unreal Engine, DOF, super resolution, megapixel, cinematic lighting, anti-aliasing, CGI, VFX, SFX, hyper maximalist, hyper-realistic, volumetric, photorealistic, full colors, volumetric lighting, realistic, 16K, sharp focus

插画风格

futuristic city landscape by Jean Giraud， art deco style, classic car

jazz playing, Art Deco, fading blue

by Andreas Rocha, a boy standing in front a tree in fire , long shadow, night, vector-art , grphic style,hyper-detailed (left) winter, inspired by Rockwell Kent, masterpiece, mininalist (right)